Constitutional Law Case Scenario

Constitutional Law Case Scenario
Constitutional Law Case Scenario: HYPOTHETICAL: In West Sussex, Alabama district judge Robert Favre runs a very formal courtroom where justice is handed out quietly but swiftly. The formality of Favre’s courtroom is demonstrated by the fact that he runs all proceedings with an iron fist. Additionally, the judge begins every day with a prayer that asks God to allow him to act judiciously and fairly when dealing with defendants. These prayers, while nondenominational, are read by different members of the clergy each week.
The pool of clergy includes several Presbyterian ministers; a few Catholic priests, but is mostly comprised of Southern Baptist ministers from the surrounding counties. These ministers are not paid, but on those days that they read the Court’s prayer, they are provided with breakfast at a local coffee shop across from the courthouse. To also help him serve justice, and to “show his place under God,” judge Favre carved a replica of the stone tablets upon which the Ten Commandments were written. He took it upon himself to hang these tablets behind his bench for all to see. When asked why he put them in his courtroom, the judge said simply “we must all realize that no matter what our laws may be, we all live under God’s law and must follow it without question.” While protesters said he should remove them, Favre refused to do so.
On January 5, 1999, Roger Vinatonka was brought into judge Favre’s courtroom to defend an accusation that he had robbed five gas stations in the past month. As this was the first case of the day judge Favre asked Southern Baptist minister Mordecai Brown to read the invocation. After he read the prayer, Vinatonka’s attorney objected that this prayer was a violation of the Establishment clause of the First Amendment. Additionally, he objected to the Ten Commandments in the courtroom, as these also violate the wall of separation between church and state. His argument was that it was a violation of his client’s rights to be subjected to such prayers when he was not Christian, and his beliefs did not include praying to God or following the Ten Commandments.
He also argued that for justice to be conducted fairly in this courtroom the prayers must be stopped and the Ten Commandments must be taken down. Favre overruled the objection and noted that even though Vinatonka was not a Christian these were ideals by which all “red blooded” Americans should live. Because Vinatonka waived his right to a jury trial the judge decided the case and found the defendant guilty. After telling him that “thou shall not steal” Vinatonka was sentenced to 3 years in a state prison.
On appeal Vinatonka’s attorney argued that the trial was unfair and biased because it was conducted under the auspices of Christian tenets, which Vinatonka did not recognize which was a direct violation of the Establishment Clause. The appeals court in Alabama affirmed the conviction and said there was no First Amendment problem. The case was appealed to the Supreme Court. As a justice on the Court, how would you rule given the line of establishment clause cases decided by the Court? Should the judge be allowed to continue the prayers? Why or why not? Is there a way that the prayers could be altered so that they would not violate the establishment clause?
How would you deal with the issue of the Ten Commandments? Should they be taken down, or can they stay as a symbol of respect for God? Finally, should Vinatonka be granted a new trial? Why or why not? You must cite cases from class to support your answers. There is no right answer, but all answers must be logical and supported with case law. Paper Submission Requirements: Your paper should be APA formatted and the body of your paper should be approximately two pages in length. References: https://constitutioncenter.org/ https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/opinions.aspx. Get Thesis writing help.
Other posts:
MKT 315 Topic 5 Benchmark Marketing Plan GCU
HLT 205V All Discussions Week 1 to Week 7
Experience Sharing Essay
Critical Analysis Portfolio

Instant Nursing Papers
Hire a Nursing Expert
Pages (550 words)
Approximate price: -

Why Choose Instant Nursing Papers?

Quality Nursing Papers

We assist students in achieving the best top-grade in their nursing papers, and in compliance with the provided instructions. Have your nursing paper written with a certified specialist Ph.D., Bachelor's, and Master's graduates with many years of experience in academic writing.

Experts with Ph.d., MDs and DNP Holders

Our writers have acquired Ph.D., MDs and DNP credentials from world class institutions. Our writers can handle papers from any discipline and can handle over 100+ subjects.

Nursing Papers Cheap

We provide a great deal of student-friendly prices and professionalism with all our nursing essay writing services. Our paper writing services have a user-friendly interface and professional nursing academic assistance. We are committed to assisting all students with their nursing assignments and projects regardless of their academic level.

Fast Paper Delivery

Our writers follow a strict schedule to ensure papers are delivered before the deadline to enable our editors to proofread before the final delivery to our customers. We strictly observe the early delivery of assignments to meet our clients' deadlines.

Plagiarism-free Nursing Papers

Our expert nursing paper writers are dedicated to conducting thorough research and writing papers from scratch to deliver original papers. To avoid paper plagiarism, all orders go through steps of writing, editing, and proofreading.

24Hour Customer Help

Our customer support is available 24/7/365 to help clients and make their paper writing services easy to use. Our experienced support team is available to answer your queries any time, 24 hours a day.

Try it now!

Calculate the price of your order

We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
Total price:
$0.00

How it works?

Follow these simple steps to get your paper done

Place your order

Fill in the order form and provide all details of your assignment.

Proceed with the payment

Choose the payment system that suits you most.

Receive the final file

Once your paper is ready, we will email it to you.

Our Nursing Papers Writing Service

We provide Nursing Assignment Services to Nursing students. Also, we are not limited to providing Nursing assignment help to students only. We also provide assignment help and solutions to community health nursing, Anatomy & Physiology, Microbiology, Biochemistry and Biophysics, and Nutrition & Dietetics.

Essays

Nursing Essays

Sit back, relax while our writers sort you out on your most daunting nursing essay queries on how to write a good nursing essay. We got you if you are looking for the best nursing essay services.

Research

Nursing Projects

It is no doubt that qualifying for a nursing career is difficult and requires a series of tests. Most nursing students must put in a lot of work in their assignments and coursework. Instantnursingpapers.com will help you answer queries such as “who can write my nursing research paper?”.

Disserations

Nursing Dissertation Help

Instantnursingpapers.com will save you the hustle of undergoing pressure or even depression while doing your nursing dissertation paper. Save yourself from all the long sleepless nights and pressure by working with our best nursing dissertation writing professionals.

Coursework

Nursing Coursework Help

If you happen to hop into our site in search of nursing coursework help, look no further. We are the number one solution for the best nursing coursework assignments. Therefore, to complete the best APA nursing coursework, seek help from professional nursing coursework experts at instantnursingpapers.com